Yet, Mr. Antolini is a very different kind of catcher from the one Holden envisioned, and the type of fall he describes is different from the one Holden imagines. Holden admires and respects him because Antolini is not only intellectual and perceptive, but he has a heart. what is the import of mr antolinis advice. bookmarked pages associated with this title. frightened, depressed, alone. 12) How is the life advice Mr. Antolini gives Holden similar to or different from the advice he has gotten from other characters, such as Old Spencer, Carl Luce, and even Phoebe? Holden's replies and descriptions of their actions are, of course, removed. Regardless of Mr. Antolini’s intentions, it’s obvious that his actions are inappropriate, since an adult in his position shouldn’t be showing any kind of physical affection to a former student, especially if that student is asleep in the adult’s house. 11 12 13. Mr. Antolini’s advice to Holden about why he should apply himself to his studies is also unconventional. what is the significance of antolinis caress. Once Mr. Antolini got married, the three of them used to play tennis together. live humbly for a cause holden start of his story by describing his last day at pencey; in that first scene, where is holden? live humbly for a cause. The fact that Mr. Antolini is trying to prevent Holden from “a fall” obviously parallels Holden’s image of the “catcher in the rye.” Yet, Mr. Antolini is a very different kind of catcher from the one Holden envisioned, and the type of fall he describes is different from the one Holden imagines. a. When James Castle committed suicide, it was Antolini who carried his bloody, broken body all the way to the infirmary. He listens to Holden more carefully than anyone yet has, and offers some earnest and insightful advice. If Holden is such a poor judge of character, there’s no reason his original impression of Mr. Antolini as a nonthreatening adult couldn’t be wrong. He gives him a whole smattering of advice - how education is really, in the end, worth the time, how Holden should find what he's passionate about b/c it'll prevent him from a fall...he gets pretty chatty in this scene. Why did Holden leave Mr. Antolinis home before morning? At chapter 24, while Mr. Antolini and Holden were talking, Mr. Antolini said, "The mark of the immature man is that he wants to die nobly for … Antolini give him shelter and advice, great advice, as a friend of the family not as a teacher. Holden and Mr. Antolini discuss Pencey, and Holden tells how he failed Oral Expression (debate). Once again, Mr. Antolini takes care not to talk down to Holden, but rather speaks to him openly and frankly, as if he were an adult. He writes down this quote and tells him to keep it with him: Mr. Antolini is about the same age as Holden's brother, D.B., and usually seems like a great guy. He is more useful to Holden as a bad example than as a mentor. It is the first piece of advice that Holden seems to take to heart in the entire novel. Mrs. Antolini understands her husband and is just looking for a companion and escort in her old age. 12.What does Holden say about him hating people, such as Ackley and Stradlater? Even so, Mr. Antolini stays very calm about the whole thing. I will not go into details, but if you want to know the truth, the reason I put this up on my blog is that (if you notice I don't really have to say it) for a long while now I've been in Holden Caulfield mood. I think Mr. Antolini was a mentor to Holden in some ways, and in other ways, he is definitely not. Once Mr. Antolini got married, the three of them used to play tennis. He initially tells us that the instructor was the best teacher he has ever known. . At the same time, if Mr. Antolini was making advances on Holden, then it's clear that perhaps Holden is right about the world - that it's incapable of offering true love, only phony attempts at connection coupled with arbitrary pain. that killed me. 12) How is the life advice Mr. Antolini gives Holden similar to or different from the advice he has gotten from other characters, such as Old Spencer, Carl Luce, and even Phoebe? 2011-09 … So far, how does Holden feel about Antolini? 8. ©2021 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. How does Mr. Antolini respond to Holden’s telephone call. Good night, handsome.” (That word “handsome” should have been a warning. Antolini’s advice is good, but his behavior seems to cancel out its value. Furthermore, the normal boundary between student and teacher already seems blurry when Holden arrives at the Antolinis’ apartment late, after an alcohol-fueled party. he know holden was in trouble. At the same time, if Mr. Antolini was making advances on Holden, then it's clear that perhaps Holden is right about the world - that it's incapable of offering true love, only phony attempts at connection coupled with arbitrary pain. What sort of talk does Mr. Antolini have with Holden about his flunking out? It looks like Holden has finally found an … He asks, “How are all your women?” He specifically inquires about Sally Hayes and Jane Gallagher. What sort of talk does Mr. Antolini have with Holden about his flunking out? At the close of Holden’s unsupervised venture through New York City, he visits Mr. Antolini, his old English teacher who is quite fond of him. I … Holden finally goes to sleep on the couch—but he suddenly wakes up because “. to tell her to meet him at the museum so he can say goodbye. Holden is disillusioned. They're all fragile around her. People also ask. Holden becomes increasingly disillusioned with Mr. Antolini. At the same time, if Mr. Antolini was making advances on Holden, then it's clear that perhaps Holden is right about the world - that it's incapable of offering true love, only phony attempts at connection coupled with arbitrary pain. to tell her to meet him at the museum so he can say goodbye. Mr. Antolinis. Mrs. Antolini is "about sixty years older than Mr. Antolini" (which we take with a grain of salt, as Holden is prone to exaggeration) and apparently has a lot of money. Do you agree with what Mr. Antolini say? It also helps to characterize Holden indirectly.). Holden thinks that Antolini should be careful or he "may get to be an alcoholic. Mr. Antolinis. One of the more controversial characters in the novel, Mr. Antolini was Holden's favorite teacher at Elkton Hills. He doesn't want them to know about being kicked out and his mother is depressed and they don't want to set her off. Now an English instructor at New York University, Antolini initially is a role model, … Holden is an interesting literary character. Holden fantasizes about protecting children from adulthood and sexuality (see Chapter 25), but Mr. Antolini describes the more frightening fall that will come if Holden himself refuses to grow up. She wanted to go with him. He doesn't want them to know about being kicked out and his mother is depressed and they don't want to set her off. He represents education not as a path of conformity but as a means for Holden to develop his unique voice and to find the ideas that are … He used to see the guy quite frequently after he left Elkton Hills. In The Catcher in the Rye, what does Mr. Antolini's quotation, from a psychoanalyst named Wilhelm Stekel, mean? He writes down this quote and tells him to keep it with him: "The mark of the immature man is that he wants to die nobly for a cause while the mark of the mature man is that he wants to live humbly for one. You’ll have to. what prompts holden … Holden instantly interprets this as … Still Holden can't handle this regardless of Antolini's intentions. Because he was awoken by Mr. Antonioni stroking his head and he thought it was a homosexual attempt . He proceeds to give Holden some VERY sound advice on life and its actually a very teacher affirming speech he makes. (There’s probably a dating website for exactly these kinds of pairings.) Holden can now dismiss Mr. Antolini's advice to him, for he can now perceive this once-respected teacher as a predator. What advice did Mr. Antonioni give Holden? Mr Spencer is, as I have written earlier, Holden’s old History teacher. he know holden was in trouble. Undeterred, Holden thanks Mr. Antolini for his advice and leaves. He tells Holden how he had lunch with his father, who told him that Holden was cutting classes and generally unprepared. he was sort of petting me or patting me on the goddam head.” It is almost tragic that the man Holden has come to for advice and protection, the man who told him that he wasn’t the first person to be confused and frightened and even sickened by human behavior, should have become emboldened by liquor to be making unmistakable homosexual overtures to his underage guest. How is Holden feeling on p. 200? Holden leaves the apartment feeling even more “confused and frightened and even sickened by human behavior” than he felt when he went there. But he tells Holden that if he applies himself in school, he will learn that many men and women have been similarly disturbed and troubled by the human condition, and he will also … Mr. Antolini tells Holden that it is the stronger man who lives humbly, rather than dies nobly, for a cause. a. Mr. Antolini tells Holden that it is the stronger man who lives humbly, rather than dies nobly, for a cause. Still, the stroking of his hair made Holden uncomfortable. You’re a student—whether the idea appeals to your or not. However, as we all know, there is the scene at the end of Chapter 24 where Holden experiences the episode of perversion from Mr. Antolini. Why does Holden misinterpret Mr. Antolini's message? Books: The Catcher in the Rye. He seems to think it's no big deal. Mr. Antolini was a favorite teacher of Holden's at an earlier school. standing on a hill That's stronger than any advice she has. Taken from the conversation between Mr Antolini and Holden Caulfield in "The catcher in the rye". The Catcher in the Rye why did Holden go to mr. antolinis house? Although Holden acknowledges this, he avoids Mr. Antolini from then on. Holden can now dismiss Mr. Antolini's advice to him, for he can now perceive this once-respected teacher as a predator. what is holden condition after antolinis caress. He used to see the guy a lot after he left Elkton Hills. They're all fragile around her. Unfortunately, though, Mr. Antolini ruins his sound advice by later stroking Holden’s head while the boy sleeps on his couch. Holden - awaking from sleep (important point) was aware of Mr. Antolini, in Holden's words, "patting or petting my head". Explain Mr. Antolini's actions and Holden's reactions when Holden visits Mr. Antolini in The Catcher in the Rye? Top Answer. Chapter 24: How does Holden characterize the Antolinis and their relationship on pp. Wiki User Answered . After his encounter with Mr. Antolini, Holden imagines a kind of symbolic death: as a deaf-mute, he wouldn’t have to speak or listen to anybody—to interact with the world at all. Why or why not? Asked by Wiki User. ", http://wiki.answers.com/Q/In_J.D._Salinger's_'The_Catcher_in_the_Rye'_what_advice_does_Mr._Antolini_give_Holden. He quotes Wilhelm Stekel: “The mark of an immature man is that he wants to die nobly for a cause, while the mark of the mature man is that he wants to live humbly for one.” Holden falls asleep on the couch. … He was no longer the little kid Antolini had taught and known. Regardless of Mr. Antolini’s intentions, it’s obvious that his actions are inappropriate, since an adult in his position shouldn’t be showing any kind of physical affection to a former student, especially if that student is asleep in the adult’s house. . How … The reader picks these things up even if Holden does not. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. What Mr. Antolini thinks will be the key to Holden's future happiness?He gives him a whole smattering of advice - how education is really, in the end, worth the time, how Holden should find what he's passionate about b/c it'll prevent him from a fall...he gets pretty chatty in this scene. Already a member? For example, his description of his host and hostess shows that Mr. Antolini is not sexually attracted to women. However he never acknowledges his own faults. What does Mr. Antonini think will be the key to Holden’s future happiness (or at least, to helping him become less depressed)? mr. antolini advice to holden is to what? Mr. Antolini calls Holden "handsome" before heading off to bed—“forgetting,” by the way, to give Holden pajamas, which means that he has to sleep in his underwear, and also making a comment about his “long legs” after quizzing him about girls—and then sits next to him in the dark (while Holden's sleeping), and pets his head. He would like to know more about Holden’s sex life. It has been an exhausting weekend. How does Mr Antolini upset and scare Holden… Holden wakes up to find Mr. Antolini sitting next to him on the floor, with his hand on Holden's head. He tells Holden how he had lunch with his father, who told him that Holden was cutting classes and generally unprepared. Holden is quite skilled at citing exactly what is wrong with other people. Summary. In The Catcher in the Rye, what does Mr. Antolini's quotation, from a psychoanalyst named Wilhelm Stekel, mean? He recognizes that Holden is different from other students, and he validates Holden’s suffering and confusion by suggesting that one day they may be worth writing about. It is easy to tell somebody else what he should do. What does Mr. Antonini think will be the key to Holden’s future happiness (or at least, to helping him become less depressed)? He advised him to attend school because Holden is in love with knowledge. Copyright © 1999 - 2021 GradeSaver LLC. Holdens discomfort signifies his maturation, his coming of age. I will not go into details, but if you want to know the truth, the reason I put this up on my blog is that (if you notice I don't really have to say it) for a long while now I've been in Holden Caulfield mood. Mr. Antolini’s advice to Holden about why he should apply himself to his studies is also unconventional. When asked about it, he pretends things are casual, but lets slip a "I'm simply sitting … Mr. Antolini addresses this speech to Holden in Chapter 24. Holden can now dismiss Mr. Antolini's advice to him, for he can now perceive this once-respected teacher as a predator. He would not let her. He says that it may be the kind where, at the age of thirty, he sits in some bar hating everyone who … Do you agree with what Mr. Antolini say? He warns Holden that he is riding towards some kind of terrible fall. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Mr. Antolini was a favorite teacher of Holden's at an earlier school. Mr Antolini is also intellectual, which Holden values. What do the details thus far indicate about Mr. Antolini? In J. D. Salinger's novel The Catcher in the Rye, what kind of "fall" does Mr. Antolini warn Holden against in Chapter 24? He stays up late because he does not want to go to bed before his wife falls asleep. Why didn’t Holden like Oral Expression class? Do you agree with what Mr. Antolini say? fatherly figure, understanding, gives advice also could be perverted. He was sure the entire world was out of step … He cares about Holden and sympathizes with him in his situation. sell out. Holden also sees that the advice Mr. Antolini gave was interesting and useful. . Mr. Antolini. and probably is only a part-time, untenured lecturer or assistant professor. Holden can now dismiss Mr. Antolini's advice to him, for he can now perceive this once-respected teacher as a predator. It is unclear exactly what this caress meant but many critics think it to be benign affection. write an essay for him. What is Mr. Antolinis advice to holden. The other is Mr Antolini, Holden’s English teacher at his old school, Elkton Hills. Both are highly significant to the novel in the way that his relationships with them are about the only good ones he has to any adults in the book. I think Salinger was just trying to make Mr. Antolini less black-and-white and avoid coming across as some perfect benevolent guru or something, and show maybe he is not necessarily a paedo but he has his quirks … His advice is good, but it is putting Holden to sleep because the intelligent boy can see that the source is a disappointed old man who has given up on life and only half-believes what he is saying. Antolini is a kind of mentor, almost an older brother. Holden feels ill when talking to Mr. Antolini and sort of misses him when he’s not around. What does Mr. Antonini think will be the key to Holden's future happiness (or at least, to helping him become less depressed)? Holden’s trust and faith in Mr. Antolini are pretty much gone. He gives him a whole smattering of advice - how education is really, in the end, worth the time, how Holden should find what he's passionate about b/c it'll prevent him from a fall...he gets pretty chatty in this scene. He married for money. What did Mr Antolini do to Holden? Holden instantly interprets this as … Naturally my class of 15 year olds were very confused by all this and I had trouble helping them make sense of it. Fictional character. Mr. Antolini believes that Holden is on track for some kind of psychological breakdown, which he describes as a “special kind of fall” in which the person falling never hits bottom. There are a number of interpretations as to what the carousel represents but it’s generally agreed that the carousel symbolizes youth and innocence. what is holden condition after antolinis caress. He warns Holden that he is riding towards some kind of terrible fall. I think Mr. Antolini gave Holden a lot of good advice and came across as very kind, but paedophiles can also seem kind to children, or can appear completely normal otherwise. Holden has already told us that Mr. Antolini was the one who picked up the body of James Castle, the student who died at Holden's old school, and carried it to the infirmary. How is the life advice Mr. Antolini gives Holden similar to or different from the advice he has gotten from other characters, such as Old Spencer, Carl Luce, and even Phoebe? What do we learn about his relationship with the Caul±elds? And finally he says, “All right. He was a mentor to Holden because he gives him advice and also is very nice to him, but he also did strange things in chapter 24 that showed me that Holden is surrounded by some bad people. And because of that it makes sense that Holden wanted to get out of their fast. Holden heads for Mr. Antolini's house. Antolini’s advice is irreproachable but conventional, all-purpose, stale and platitudinous. Holden loves the museum because. But regardless of the truth about Mr. Antolini’s intentions, the … His short night at the Antolinis' has taught him another of life's painful lessons: His golden idol has feet of clay. Log in here. How is that similar or different to the lecture from Mr. Spencer? Mr. Antolini tells Holden that he is headed for a serious fall and that he is the type who may die nobly for a highly unworthy cause. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. Holden compares him to D.B., whom he clearly admires despite his brother's relocation to Hollywood. At the same time, if Mr. Antolini was making advances on Holden, then it's clear that perhaps Holden is right about the world - that it's incapable of offering true love, only phony attempts at connection coupled with arbitrary pain. Are you a teacher? Holden and Mr. Antolini discuss Pencey, and Holden tells how he failed Oral Expression (debate). See Answer. Who is Mr Antolini and why does Holden like him? In The Catcher in the Rye, Mr. Antolini is one of the few adult characters with whom Holden had a really good relationship. what is the import of mr antolinis advice. Top subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences, The gist of the advice that Mr.Antolini gives Holden in Chapter 24 is that he is going to have to find out where he wants to go in life and then, “your first move will be to apply yourself in school. Antolini’s remarks become more and more suggestive as he becomes more and more intoxicated. I won't go as far as to say Mr. Antolini was a sexual deviant, but how his life was explained to us (the much older wife, letting Holden in on such short notice, alcohol consumption) makes him a person to be more cautious of. He also offers long-winded theories concerning Holden that the boy could do without. Mrs. Antolini, he says, is "about sixty years older than Mr. Antolini" and has a lot of money. According to Holden Mr. Antolini was being “perverty” (Salinger 212). From the way Holden talked about it, I think that Mr. Antolini was. When Holden freaks out, Mr. Antolini says he was "Just admiring–" but Holden cuts him off. He has given up on any intellectual aspirations he probably once had and now wants a soft life with good food and plenty of liquor, along with the protective “cover” of marriage to disguise his homosexuality in an era when gay men still had to remain in the closet. Mr. Antolini tried to give Holden a reason to be motivated and in which case not to give up so easily. By Holden saying this he’s showing that even someone you hate you can still have feelings for them. Page 210 Mr. Antolini further explains the “fall” he is envisioning, saying that it is experienced by men who cannot deal with the environment around them. Stradlater uses holden to. Why or why not? Rather than dooming himself to a miserable existence or self-destruction, Mr. Antolini tells Holden that he should instead make an active effort to better himself. what does holden think of his brother D.B. Taken from the conversation between Mr Antolini and Holden Caulfield in "The catcher in the rye". In "The Catcher in the Rye", how does Holden describe his mother? Page 210 Mr. Antolini further explains the “fall” he is envisioning, saying that it is experienced by men who cannot deal with the environment around them. Once again, Mr. Antolini takes care not to talk down to Holden, but rather speaks to him openly and frankly, as if he were an adult. move out west work at a gas station and become a deaf mute. What is their relationship? . When Holden imagines living in a cabin near the woods, what rule does he have for his visitors? The gist of the advice that Mr.Antolini gives Holden in Chapter 24 is that he is going to have to find out where he wants to go in life and then “your first move will be to apply yourself in school. He is a "kept man" of an older woman who is "lousy with dough." fatherly figure, understanding, gives advice also could be perverted. He recognizes that Holden is different from other students, and he validates Holden’s suffering and confusion by suggesting that one day they may be worth writing about. Holden notes: “They were always kissing each other a lot in public.” This strongly suggests that theirs is what the French call a mariage de convenance. Holden - awaking from sleep (important point) was aware of Mr. Antolini, in Holden's words, "patting or petting my head". It is the advice of a man who has sold out for security and comfort. You’re in love with knowledge.”, “. He goes to Mr. Antolini's apartment because he needs a place to stay for the night. why does holden write phoebe. Holden interprets the caress as a homosexual overture. flag * Bipeda Implume Mar 09, 2016 08:24AM 0 votes Maybe I come from a … However, as we all know, there is the scene at the end of Chapter 24 where Holden experiences the episode of perversion from Mr. Antolini. Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now. How did phoebe surprise Holden and what was his reaction? one of holdens favorite expressions is. He represents. He sleeps on a bench at the waiting room in Grand Central Station until about 9 a.m. Having second thoughts about Mr. Antolini's intentions, he wonders if he should have returned and stayed there. It is the first piece of advice that Holden seems to take to heart in the entire novel. He gives him advice … At the same time, if Mr. Antolini was making advances on Holden, then it's clear that perhaps Holden is right about the world - that it's incapable of offering true love, only phony attempts at connection coupled with arbitrary pain. He has slept only two or three hours since Saturday morning, two days ago. Teachers and parents! 199–200? Holden is very tired. frightened, depressed, alone. everything stays the same. Mr. Antolini reveals to Holden that he is, in fact, not the first person to feel the way he’s feeling. He goes to Mr. Antolini's apartment because he needs a place to stay for the night. While Holden heads over to Mr. Antolini's place, he tells us more. But even this fantasy involves meeting another deaf-mute, because he just can’t stand to be alone. you’re not the first person who was ever confused and frightened and even sickened by human behavior.”, Holden observes that the older man is drinking heavily throughout their conversation. Undeterred, Holden thanks Mr. Antolini for his advice and leaves. why does holden write phoebe. Young, articulate, and popular, Antolini is also intensely caring as evidenced by his … I mean I sort of missed them'"(206). among holdnes fantasies is. Mr. Antolini believes that Holden is on track for some kind of psychological breakdown, which he describes as a “special kind of fall” in which the person falling never hits bottom. How is that similar or different to the lecture from Mr… Holden's replies and descriptions of their actions are, of course, removed. It is dawn on Monday as Holden leaves the Antolinis' apartment. what is the significance of antolinis caress. To have a certain sense of angst is normal for a person of his age. This would explain why Holden was so terrified about Mr. Antolini. How does Mr. Antolini greet Holden? List some of the people and actions Holden sees as phony, and then discuss how he is phony himself in. 2.Evaluate Mr. Antolini’s advice. Holden says "I sorta missed them. He is intelligent and sensitive enough to make keen observations about people but not yet old enough to be able to analyze and digest their deeper significance. Sign up now, Latest answer posted August 17, 2012 at 3:55:53 AM, Latest answer posted March 19, 2020 at 11:46:52 PM, Latest answer posted May 26, 2012 at 7:38:18 PM, Latest answer posted June 19, 2018 at 3:09:32 AM, Latest answer posted July 08, 2018 at 9:53:59 AM. Holden can now dismiss Mr. Antolini's advice to him, for he can now perceive this once-respected teacher as a predator. 13. When he awakens, he finds Mr… Walking up on Fifth Avenue, searching for an inexpensive restaurant in which to eat breakfast, he suddenly feels … Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Holden may overreact to the situation, perhaps even misjudge it, when he awakens to find Antolini patting him on the head on the night he stays in the Antolinis' apartment, but it clearly is at least an uncomfortable and inappropriate situation. What Mr. Antolini thinks will be the key to Holden's future happiness? Holden can now dismiss Mr. Antolini's advice to him, for he can now perceive this once-respected teacher as a predator. He says that it may be the kind where, at the age of thirty, he sits in some bar hating everyone who comes in looking as if he … Holden says that Antolini teaches at New York University, but he arrived there late in life after leaving Elkton Hills prep school (for what reason?) Tonight he wants to discuss pedagogy more than Holden cares to. He tells Holden to hurry back as soon as he picks up his bags from Grand Central Station. His goal for Holden being to see school as something he loves and not something he is being forced to do. Holden has always seen school as something that requires him to give up his unique viewpoint, but Mr. Antolini now suggests that Holden can use education to further define himself and, in doing so, facilitate his personal growth. 2.Evaluate Mr. Antolini’s advice. Not affiliated with Harvard College. Anyway, I kept walking and … What is the life advice Mr. Antolini gives Holden? We’ve discounted annual subscriptions by 50% for COVID-19 relief—Join Now! Like most heavy drinkers, he likes big highballs heavily laced with whiskey. Unfortunately, though, Mr. Antolini ruins his sound advice by later stroking Holden’s head while the boy sleeps on his couch. She has bought herself a husband who is a good host and a good conversationalist.
Directv Satellite History, Arise And Pray, Michael Myers Ringtone, Dingo Adopt Me Wiki, Bernini Sculptures Borghese Gallery, Promesas Financieras En La Biblia,